top of page

Lo que Pudiese Ser: Mr. Fox’s Longing For The Fantastic Future He Could’ve Had

5 minutes ago
7 min read

Lo que pudiese ser, the Spanish subjunctive conjugation, lives in my mind rent free since it linguistically embeds a question that all future-oriented students and hopeless romantics alike have into the language itself: what could be? Or what might yet be? The phrase captures the melancholy of imagining the lives we might have lived, since every choice that brings us to the present also leaves other versions of ourselves unrealized. Yet like Spanish grammar itself, we are often left wondering what our unrealized lives could’ve been since we never discover what they would actually have entailed. While Mr. Fox, the protagonist of Wes Anderson’s film Fantastic Mr. Fox, is not Spanish, he might as well be the subjunctive animalized. He has a wife, a son, a home, and a stable profession, but he remains dissatisfied with the limitations of domesticity; his former life as a thief represents an exciting path. While we’re made out to believe that Mr. Fox’s restlessness is a product of “peaked-in-my-thieving-days,” it’s more specifically a longing for the possibility of a future where he didn’t have to give up being fantastic, where he could continue to exercise his ingenuity, take risks, and distinguish himself through extraordinary heists. Of course, the film does not establish that he would necessarily have achieved a better life by mimicking Swiper from Dora the Explorer; rather, he imagines that his former identity offered the possibility of remaining fantastic that his present life no longer allows him to pursue. In Fantastic Mr. Fox, Mr. Fox’s nostalgia is directed as much toward the fox he believes he could have become as toward the thief he once was. His attempts to reclaim that imagined future reveal how the possibilities that make life feel expansive can become a prison when we mistake them for the lives we were meant to live. Anderson’s film ultimately suggests that evolution doesn’t necessitate the abandonment of the self we might have been, but learning to make new opportunities from the lives we actually inhabit. 


Mr. Fox’s dissatisfaction with domestic life stems from a longing for the future where he could continue being fantastic that his former identity seemed to promise. The film opens with a flashback scene of Mr. Fox and his wife Felicity stealing birds from the squab shack. Anderson, in opening with this scene, establishes Mr. Fox’s past self as a thief who uses his ingenuity to accomplish a grand heist. This is the fox Mr. Fox genuinely was, but it also provides the foundation for the imagined version of Mr. Fox who could continue living this way without surrendering his exceptional qualities to the responsibilities of domestic life. We start to see this tension when Mr. Fox complains that he does not “want to live in a hole anymore” because it makes him “feel poor.” Felicity responds that they are poor, “but happy,” acknowledging their material limitations while insisting that they do not diminish the value of the life they have built together. Mr. Fox’s dismissive “comme ci, comme ça,” however, suggests that happiness alone can’t settle his dissatisfaction. He does not necessarily deny that he is happy; rather, he seems unwilling to accept that happiness is sufficient when his life falls short of what he believes he could have become. The underground home represents the domesticity that he feels limited by, and he measures it against the imagined future in which he could have remained fantastic. To solve his gripes with his humble den life, Mr. Fox moves his family to a tree house. The tree house is elevated and offers a broader view of the surrounding landscape, while its proximity to Boggis, Bunce, and Bean foreshadows the risks that Mr. Fox will take to reclaim his former identity. If the underground home symbolizes the life he actually lives, the tree house makes tangible the possibility of another. We do need to distinguish the fact that his past life as a thief is real, while the future he associates with it is not. Mr. Fox can’t know whether continuing to steal would have made him happier or whether that life would eventually have imposed limitations of 


(Courtesy of 20th Century Fox)


its own. Because his alternative life remains unrealized, he can imagine it as a life of seemingly limitless possibility, untouched by the compromises of domesticity. So really, Mr. Fox’s nostalgia is directed towards a future que pudiese ser, one that could be. And of course, the fact that it’s unrealized allows it to remain more attractive than the life he actually has. The grass is greener on the lawn of a tree house that isn’t yours yet after all. 


Unable to accept the distance between the future he imagines he could have lived, and the life he actually inhabits, Mr. Fox attempts to reclaim his lost potential by repeating the heists that once defined him. His return to stealing from Boggis, Bunce, and Bean, despite his promise to Felicity that he would abandon his dangerous profession, suggests that he is seeking more than food or drink. While Bean’s cider seems like quite the immediate reward, we notice Mr. Fox gets increasingly ambitious in his exploits when the amount of food Felicity finds in their pantry grows exponentially scene to scene. The abundance is honestly quite comical, since there’s only so much cider and sausage links a fox family can consume. The film title is Fantastic Mr. Fox, not The Hungry Hungry Mr. Fox…Yet, in an act of hubris, Mr. Fox keeps going. It now becomes evident that Mr. Fox wants to demonstrate that he is still daring and fantastic by increasing the magnitude of his thefts. He mistakes his ability to perform his former identity for the ability to reclaim the possibilities that identity seemed to promise. Each sausage link, chicken breast, or apple gives him temporary confirmation that he is still the fox he remembers, but this assurance is fleeting, so he must demonstrate his abilities again. Mr. Fox must therefore keep proving himself, turning identity into something he feels compelled to perform rather than a set of qualities he might express in different ways. When our identities become more like a performance, as Mr. Fox demonstrates, the futures that we believe we may realize start to feel like things we are obligated to make come true. The future that Mr. Fox longs for can thus also be seen as a piece of his performed fantasticness. Mr. Fox then keeps digging himself into a deeper hole, where the more he tries to recover his former self, the more he depends on repeating the behavior associated with it. However, this pursuit does not stay in the tunnels of 


(Courtesy of 20th Century Fox)


Mr. Fox’s private crisis: Stealing does not go without consequence, so the farmers eventually retaliate and destroy all of the animals’ homes. Mr. Fox’s attempt to reclaim forces his family and community to endure the consequences of actions driven partly by his dissatisfaction with his own life. They are all driven underground, ironic since the catalyst for the whole film was in part Mr. Fox’s desire to get above ground. While the farmers are responsible for their own violence, we still need to recognize that it was Mr. Fox’s refusal to accept the limitations of his circumstances that contributed to a situation in which everyone else’s freedom is threatened. Ironically Mr. Fox’s inability to bear to live in a hole helps drive everyone back underground. His attempts to escape a life he considered restrictive ends up restringing the lives of those around him. The imagined future that once promised the freedom of being fantastic has now become the prison he tried to escape because Mr. Fox cannot accept that he might have to live differently from the fox he imagined he could become. 


If repeating his former behavior can’t restore the future he imagined, the possibility of moving forward requires Mr. Fox to find a different relationship with his past. Now that they’re stuck underground, the animals can’t simply restore their former homes and resume their lives as though nothing happened. Mr. Fox’s actions have completely changed their living circumstances, making a literal return to the past impossible. Luckily, Mr. Fox is still a witty and resourceful fox who is capable of recognizing opportunities. Even when hopeless, Mr. Fox keeps searching and eventually, lo and behold, he finds a sewer tunnel that leads to a supermarket. The supermarket is therefore a representation of the way Mr. Fox uses his familiar qualities to find a new way of providing for his community. I guess you could still consider eating the supermarket food stealing since I doubt the supermarket takes the equivalent of Flex in Mr. Fox’s community, but the important difference is that Mr. Fox is no longer simply trying to recreate the circumstances of his former heists. He is responding to the circumstances that actually exist. Mr. Fox’s ingenuity, which used to serve his need to prove that he was still fantastic, now helps the animals survive together. The communal meal that follows reinforces the idea that instead of pursuing extraordinary exploits to affirm his individual identity, he now shares with the animals the resources that allow them to build a life under changed conditions. The supermarket, therefore, represents a new possibility emerging from the ruins of the old one. This doesn’t mean that he has completely abandoned his former self, nor does it prove that his nostalgia for it has disappeared. Rather, the film suggests that he does not have to stop being the fox he was; he has to stop believing that being that fox requires him to live the life he once lived. Mr. Fox’s growth thus lies in recognizing that his former identity does not dictate the only future available to him. 


(Courtesy of 20th Century Fox)


Maybe the melancholy of lo que pudiese ser lies more in the temptation to believe that the lives we never lived would have been better than the ones we did. Mr. Fox’s tragedy isn’t that he can no longer be the fantastic fox he was once, but that he initially mistakes being fantastic for having to remain the fox he used to be. When he tries to reclaim the future he imagined his past promised him, he risked the very life that might have given his intrinsic qualities new meaning. But fortunately, the supermarket at the end of the film offers him the space to fully express his fantasticness without having to perfectly recreate his thieving. Growing up and changing, after all, doesn’t mean we have to abandon every version of ourselves. The lives we leave unrealized shouldn’t become the standards against which we judge the lives we have. Mr. Fox can still be fantastic, it’s not something that pudiese haber sido but si pasó. His fantasticness is not something that could’ve been, but something that presently occurred. 



Luna Monje Indahsari is a freshman at Columbia College studying Economics-Mathematics with a Political Science minor. It takes very little prompting in a conversation to get her to go on about how amazing the Star Wars prequel trilogy is.

bottom of page